Clayface Movie Review | This Was Not What I Expected

The DC Universe just got a little bit bigger and a little bit more complicated with the new film Clayface. I have to be up front with the fact that I am not a Clayface fan, and I went into this film without any expectations or hope of liking the movie. On top of that, I’m definitely squeamish. I don’t really like body horror stories that involve needles, knives, and squishy blood. It’s just not my thing. So, I really didn’t have much hope for this film, which just goes to show that you never know where you will find a good story.

Movie poster for 'Clayface' featuring a dramatic close-up of a face with a melting clay effect, with the title prominently displayed in red against a dark background and release date at the bottom.

Clayface wasn’t at all what I expected. I found myself turning away from the screen multiple times, only to keep turning back because I wanted to know what was going to happen next. This was a movie I should have hated but didn’t and for me, that makes it one of the most interesting new additions to any superhero universe in a very long time. So, why did this film work and will it work for you?

The Story

Tom Rhys Harries plays Matt Hagan, a Hollywood actor whose star is rising and audiences love him. He gets the biggest breakthrough in his career just as he makes an awful decision and spends a night with the very hot girlfriend of a local gangster who takes out his revenge on Matt by slicing up his pretty face into a bunch of pieces, and then he slices it some more. That’s one of the signature moves of this film in that it pushes you to the extreme edge of where you think it will go, and then stops for just a second before pushing further into that uncomfortable zone that makes it almost impossible to pull back from.

So, here’s Matt, an actor who is superb at shifting between characters, bringing each one of them to life suddenly disfigured in a way that radically changes his life and he loses everything. Desperate, for any chance at normalcy, he visits Dr. Caitlyn Corr whose research trials work to combat disease through experimental treatments involving nanocells that act like stem cells that help to repair the body on a cellular level. The treatment works, but not like either of them expect, and Matt discovers that his body is changing and he is losing control of holding his identity together, and the nanocells respond to what he is feeling, which leads to some life changing choices for him and the people around him.

That’s the basic setup, and I am going to leave it there because I don’t want to spoil how this story unfolds because it’s the pulling back of those layers that makes it such an interesting and thoughtful film.

You can read the review below or watch the video here:

When Body Horror Becomes Identity Horror

This film is really uncomfortable, and it doesn’t try to make you feel better about the horrors that Matt experiences. It quickly establishes him as a likable, compelling character who feels like the kind of down-to-earth people everyone wants in their lives. He is genuinely a good guy with a kind heart, and you want him to win. That’s what makes his disfiguration so uncomfortable. We know what he lost and see the hopelessness of his situation, which makes so many of his bad decisions understandable because any life is better than the life he has after Markos Szabo butchered him and used social media to discredit him.

The setup is cruel on every level and it shreds even his personal identity, leaving him no safe place to exist within his own skin. That’s how this film turns what is a body horror film into an identity horror story, making Matt an incredibly complex man who still wants to be  a good person despite doing some really horrible things. The film subverts your expectations of what he’s going through and how he will get out of it, making you painfully aware that as his experimental treatment continues to work and reprogram Matt’s body on a genetic level, it’s doing the same thing to him on a psychological level that leaves him struggling to remember who he is in order to push his identity to the surface.

Close-up of a distressed man with blonde hair, looking through a glass barrier surrounded by colorful neon lights.

Why the Story Works

It’s that deeply layered construction of Matt’s characterthat makes this story work, and it’s also how the film uses humor as a pressure valve to release just enough tension at the right moment to keep us firmly rooted in Matt’s conflict. We can’t help wanting him to succeed.

What really sets this film apart are the performances. Tom Rhys Harries is a compelling actor who feels like he has come out of nowhere despite being in films for nearly two decades. This might just be his breakthrough film because that’s how good he is in it. The technology and effects help to accentuate everything he gets right as an actor by giving us the physical deformation of his body in a way that makes logical sense and looks physically plausible. That physical deformation becomes a character in itself rather than just a costume that he wears because it’s an outward reflection of the emotions that he has roiling inside of him.

Naomi Ackie plays Dr. Caitlyn Corr, and she’s such a good fit for this role and for the relationship that develops between her and Matt. She really becomes the emotional center of the film in an increasingly important way as he struggles to control his transformations. She is one of the few people he can trust, but part of that is her own personal and professional need to monitor his condition. However, these two actors have real chemistry on screen and she allows us to focus on the man who is getting overwhelmed by all of the other people who seem to be floating to the surface of his skin.

A smiling young man in a blue suit waves to fans at a red carpet event, while a crowd holds promotional flyers in the background.

Heroism and Villainy

It’s also really important to understand that Matt doesn’t just wake up on some random Tuesday and decide to be a villain or a hero. He is forced into this state by someone else’s cruelty and that cruelty is compounded by the people who should be there to help him, but aren’t.

The one thing this movie really nails is that you get a real look at the nature of friendship, love, trust, and heroism… along with how the violation of these things paired with the betrayal of the court system can erase everything that grounds and stabilizes a good person. Without an anchor to help Matt control his emotions and his identity, he begins to spiral as he transforms, straying into the edges of villainy. That is such a human spin to give this character, and it makes me care about what happens to “Clayface.”

What Doesn’t Work

As for what doesn’t work, I don’t have many complaints about the film. I think it could have been shorter, but that’s a common compliant about most films nowadays. It could have had has less body horror,  but that’s my personal preference, not an actual problem. The music is forgettable, which was disappointing since I love a good soundtrack.

The biggest failing is how the film’s R-rating has been communicated to audiences. This is an R-rated film and people are going to bring their kids to the new DC superhero movie without paying attention to the rating because they have been trained for decades to think superhero stories are family friendly, even with the type of violence that we get within the stories. This isn’t that kind of film.

The R-rating is a “hard” R. Don’t bring your young children unless you want to scar them for life and give them body horror nightmares. The marketing for this film really should have done more to highlight that R out of respect for the audience. The studio should have done better with the marketing.

What Does Clayface Mean for the DC Universe

Finally, I think we need to talk about how Clayface fits into the DCU.  Everyone has been talking about how Batman and Wonder Woman should have been the next films produced after Superman, and I respect that thinking. However, after seeing Clayface, Supergirl, and part of Lanterns, I actually like the fact that the new DC Universe isn’t just a carbon copy production plan of every other playbook out there.

We all have ideas about the 3 pillars of the universe, which are Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman. Any film that comes out with these characters will receive a grueling comparison to past characters and past DCUs.

With Clayface, I found myself appreciating how this film filled out ordinary life within Gotham. That in turn made me appreciate how Supergirl filled out the wider universe, and Superman established the center of the story. There’s no doubt that it’s a costly decision to fill out the universe with secondary stories. However, the benefit is that when Batman hits the screen, we will know this world and if that film’s script does its job right, it can just focus on Batman within an established world without having to do a lot of worldbuilding.

Screenshot of Matt Hagan walking through Gotham.

With Superman, Supergirl, Lanterns, and now with Clayface, we are getting a wide view of the superhero spectrum that actually runs from iconically good to truly evil people and where they all fall on the spectrum as each film seems to be asking what it means to be good in a corrupt world that constantly tries to turn goodness into a weakness or fault to be exploited by a villain.

I don’t know what James Gunn has in mind for the future, but there is something about the addition of Clayface that actually makes this universe feel more like the real world than some of the past DC universe films. So, while it’s not a perfect movie, it has bought some time for the franchise.

Final Recommendation

So, there’s a lot to think about here, but the question remains, is Clayface ticket-worthy? Now, I have been a comics and superhero fan for a very very long time, and this is not a character I ever fave a second thought to because I just never liked him and yet it’s an easy film to recommend… with a few caveats.

If you enjoy straightforward stories that include layered characters that add complexity to a simple story, I think you’ll like this film, especially if you enjoy stories within superhero universes. I can’t tell you how you will likely feel about this film if you are a Clayface fan, but I enjoyed it.

However, I don’t think Clayface is a film that I will be able to see twice because I just can’t do the body horror, knives, and needles. If you are sensitive to this kind of thing in a film, if you don’t like horror, or if you are expecting a shining star of a superhero, this is going to be a hard sell. If you have small children, please leave them at home.

What Do You Think?

So, Clayface. Have you seen it? I’m really curious about what you think of this film. Did you like it? Did it make you think differently about the character or was it disappointing? Let me know what you think of this view into the world of the DC universe.

If you enjoyed this review, please give it a like and subscribe for more. You can also visit my YouTube channel at @ErinUnderwood for more videos.


Image credits: Promotional images courtesy of DC Studios and Warner Bros. Pictures. Additional stills sourced from IMDb and the official Clayface trailer. Images used for editorial commentary and review.

Unknown's avatar

About Erin Underwood

BIO: Erin Underwood is the senior event content producer for MIT Technology Review’s emerging technology events. On the side, she reads, writes, and edits SF. Erin also reviews movies, TV series, and books on YouTube.
This entry was posted in Movies & TV and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply